MyPillow Pillow Comparison: Which One Is Right for You?

MyPillow Pillow Comparison

If you’ve been searching for the perfect pillow to support your head, neck, and spine while delivering unmatched comfort, you’ve likely come across the popular MyPillow brand. MyPillow has garnered a devoted following due to its patented interlocking fill, machine washability, and renowned durability. Still, with several options available—Classic, Premium, Giza, and the all-new 2.0—figuring out which MyPillow best suits your needs can be a bit confusing. In this MyPillow Pillow Comparison, we’re going to break down all four major MyPillow types so you can choose the best fit for your unique sleep style.

What Makes MyPillow So Special?

Before diving into each pillow’s differences, let’s talk about what they all have in common. Every MyPillow is designed using a patented interlocking fill. Unlike many pillows on the market that are stuffed with feathers, down alternative, or memory foam layers that can flatten, MyPillow’s fill retains a supportive, adjustable shape. This means you can mold your pillow to your preferred comfort level—great news for side, back, and even stomach sleepers.

On top of that, all MyPillow pillows boast:

10-year warranty – Reflecting the brand’s confidence in the product’s longevity.
60-day money back guarantee – If you’re not convinced, you can return it within 60 days.
Machine washable and dryable – Keeping them fresh and fluffy is a breeze.
Made in the USA – With the exception of the Giza cover fabric, which is imported for extra luxury, everything else is proudly made in the States.

Thanks to their signature fill and durability, MyPillow owners routinely report better sleep, reduced neck stiffness, and improved comfort overall. But which model should you pick? Let’s walk through each one.

MyPillow Pillow Comparison

1. The Classic MyPillow

This is the original MyPillow that started it all and remains a favorite for many long-time loyalists. The Classic has what’s referred to as a “knife edge.” This simply means that the seams meet at the edges in a more traditional manner, without an added gusset (the gusset is an extra fabric strip around the perimeter that can add height).

Who Is the Classic Ideal For?

Sleepers who love a more traditional-feeling pillow shape.
Those who don’t need an extra lofty silhouette.
Anyone who wants to experience MyPillow’s patented fill with minimal fuss.

You can choose between Medium and Firm loft for the Classic MyPillow, ensuring that whether you like your head cradled in softness or propped with a bit more support, there’s an option for you.

What Are Users Saying?
Plenty of My Pillow pillow reviews rave about the Classic’s longevity—one customer reported their original MyPillow lasted nine years! Another noted that it ended chronic shoulder and back pain by providing just the right combination of support and moldability. People also love how easy it is to keep fresh. As one longtime user said, “I can wash it frequently, and it always comes back just like new.”

2. The Premium MyPillow

The Premium MyPillow took the original design and added a two-inch gusset around the edges. This design innovation increases the overall loft and can offer enhanced neck support—especially helpful if you find that your head needs a little more elevation to stay aligned with your spine throughout the night.

Who Is the Premium Ideal For?

Side sleepers and back sleepers who prefer a higher loft.
People who feel they need more neck support than the Classic might offer.
Those who enjoy a slightly plusher, elevated shape.

It comes in four different loft levels. While that might sound excessive, this variation ensures you can truly fine-tune how much fill best accommodates your sleeping style. Queen and King sizes both include the gusset.

What Are Users Saying?
Customers appreciate the added height and slightly roomier feel. In fact, some mention that “the Premium was perfect for long-term comfort because it supports the neck so well,” and that it noticeably alleviated stiffness after a few nights of use. Others love how well it retains its shape, even after years of nightly sleep and regular washing.

3. The Giza (Premium Giza Elegance) MyPillow

The Premium Giza MyPillow, also called the “Giza Elegance,” steps things up another notch in the luxury department. It utilizes a 100% Giza cotton case known for its softness, breathability, and gentle feel on the skin. If you love the idea of a high-end, silky exterior—akin to upscale bedding—this could be your sweet spot.

Like the Premium, this option also includes the gusset for added loft. Plus, it’s distinguished by colored piped cording around the edges, which can help you quickly identify your loft level at a glance.

Who Is the Giza Ideal For?

Those looking for a slightly more luxurious fabric touch.
Anyone desiring the premium gusset design plus a sleek, soft outer casing.
Shoppers who want a breathable, high-thread-count cotton exterior.

Yes, the Giza cotton case is sourced from overseas, so this pillow is not 100% made in the United States. However, the patented fill and final manufacturing are still proudly done in America.

What Are Users Saying?
Reviewers often emphasize the luxurious feel of the Giza cover: “It’s so silky-soft that I sleep cooler,” and “It’s worth the upgrade if you’re big on comfort.” Others mention that while you may not feel the fabric against your face when the pillowcase is on, the breathable cotton does help regulate heat and elevate the overall sleeping experience.

4. The MyPillow 2.0

Dubbed the “cooling” MyPillow, the MyPillow 2.0 is all about temperature regulation. It still boasts the same patented, interlocking fill. However, the fabric on the outside has been re-engineered for better breathability and a cooler night’s sleep.

Who Is the MyPillow 2.0 Ideal For?

Hot sleepers who often flip their pillow to the “cool side.”
Anyone experiencing night sweats or hot flashes.
Those who live in warmer climates or want maximum temperature balance.

Reviews of the MyPillow 2.0 have been glowing. Many note how they no longer spend time flipping and adjusting their pillows at night. One user in Florida raved, “True cooling tech for someone that has hot flashes and lives by the beach in FL.” Another simply said, “It stayed cool all night, no more flipping the pillow over.”

Comparing the Differences at a Glance: MyPillow Pillow Comparison

Classic MyPillow: Knife edge, minimal loft, two fill options (Medium or Firm).
Premium MyPillow: Two-inch gusset, four loft levels, more customization, extra neck support.
Giza (Premium Giza Elegance) MyPillow: Similar design to Premium but features luxurious 100% Giza cotton outer cover and colored piping.
MyPillow 2.0: Innovative cooling fabric for temperature regulation, same patented fill, available in four loft levels.

Is MyPillow Right for You?
Considering MyPillow’s wide range of fill levels and its adjustable nature, there truly is an option for almost everyone—side sleepers, back sleepers, and even stomach sleepers. Plus, the brand’s renowned durability and easy wash-and-dry routine consistently earn rave reviews. Customers frequently mention their pillows last for a decade or more and remain as supportive as day one.

Real-Life Experiences: What Customers Love

Pain Relief: Many reviewers say MyPillow helped them conquer neck and shoulder pains that regular pillows couldn’t fix.
Longevity: “I have had mine for nine years, and it is still as comfortable as the day I bought it,” is a common sentiment, showing they truly stand the test of time.
Travel-Friendly: Some folks won’t leave home without their MyPillow. Whether on business trips or vacations, they stash it in their suitcase to ensure they continue sleeping well.
Easy Maintenance: The machine-washable fill is a winner. Pillows can harbor dust mites and allergens, so the ability to wash and thoroughly dry yours is a major perk. After washing, most find it feels even more fluffy and supportive.

MyPillow Pillow Comparison: It’s All About Personal Preference

Whether you select the Classic for its no-frills simplicity, the Premium for more loft and neck support, the Giza for a dash of luxury with that 100% Giza cotton, or the 2.0 for its game-changing cooling technology, you can rest easy knowing you’ve invested in a quality, long-lasting product. The key is picking the model that aligns with your sleeping style and comfort preferences.

Ready to Sleep Better Tonight?
For a limited time, you can save up to 80% on your MyPillow order. Be sure to use promo code “Remarkable” at checkout for exclusive pricing and enjoy free shipping on orders over $75. Thousands of shoppers have already discovered their best night’s sleep with MyPillow—now it’s your turn to experience why so many people can’t stop raving about these pillows.